Scotland: gratuitous alienations by individual debtors

Produced in partnership with James Lloyd of Harper Macleod LLP and Stephanie Carr of Thorntons Law LLP
Practice notes

Scotland: gratuitous alienations by individual debtors

Produced in partnership with James Lloyd of Harper Macleod LLP and Stephanie Carr of Thorntons Law LLP

Practice notes
imgtext

For any Insolvency process to operate effectively, it is essential the person appointed to wind-up the insolvent estate has powers that enable them to scrutinise dealings by the insolvent party with their assets prior to the commencement of the formal insolvency process. Absent such powers, parties or companies facing insolvency could take steps to alienate assets to connected third parties for less than their true worth to the prejudice of the general body of creditors. The purpose of this Practice Note is to consider the circumstances in which such transactions can be challenged, the grounds upon which challenges will be upheld by the courts and the effect of such a successful challenge. For details of the equivalent rules for Scottish corporate debtors, see Practice Note: Scotland: Antecedent transactions by corporate debtors. For a glossary of commonly used Scottish insolvency terms, see Practice Note: Glossary of Scottish insolvency words and expressions.

Historically, such transactions have been challengeable under the common law on the basis that they

James Lloyd
James Lloyd

James heads the firm's Insolvency team and has advised on corporate and personal insolvency related matters for a number of years. He advises creditors, banks and insolvency practitioners on all aspects of insolvency litigation.

Chambers UK Guide to the Legal Profession lists James as a "Leader in the Field" in both Restructuring/Insolvency and Personal Insolvency, where he is noted for having a strong reputation in the market, his clients appreciate his ability to "do an extremely good job under difficult circumstances." Sources note "He's good. He tells you as it is."

James has been recognised as a "World Leader" in commercial litigation by Who's Who Legal.

James is a member of the team that won the prestigious "Insolvency Team of the Year" award at the Law Awards of Scotland 2012.

Stephanie Carr
Stephanie Carr

Solicitor / Partner, Thorntons Law LLP


Stephanie joined Thorntons Law LLP as a Partner in 2023. She has over 18 years' experience acting for a variety of clients in a wide range of contentious personal and corporate insolvency cases, as a result of which she has been accredited, and re-accredited, as a specialist in Insolvency Law by the Law Society of Scotland.

She is well known and respected in insolvency circles. She passed the Joint Insolvency Examination Board ("JIEB") exams in liquidation and personal insolvency and has a wide breadth of knowledge as a result of having attended the modules for the exams, where she also obtained a better understanding of the practical workings of the insolvency processes. 

She also regularly acts for clients in both secured and unsecured debt recovery matters and advises on a number of diligence measures open to them. Stephanie has advised and represented clients in a wide range of disputes in the Sheriff Court, the Court of Session and tribunals. She has been the principal adviser to clients including government bodies, companies of all sizes and their directors, private and registered social landlords, individuals, insolvency practitioners, creditors and financial institutions.

Stephanie is ranked as an individual in Chambers and Partners UK for Insolvency/Restructuring with the commentary that she has "a deep and extensive knowledge of the full span of restructuring matters, including insolvency related litigation, advising Directors on their duties and corporate restructuring". 

Powered by Lexis+®
Jurisdiction(s):
United Kingdom
Key definition:
Gratuitous alienation definition
What does Gratuitous alienation mean?

The Scottish equivalent of transactions at an undervalue. The time period is longer, extending to five years in corporate transactions with associated companies, and defences differ.

Popular documents